Thursday, May 29, 2008

Transcript - What Senator Clinton Said

To help better understand the controversy surrounding Senator Clinton's remarks about Democratic Presidential Candidates continuing to contest primaries into June, here's the newspaper's summary of the events following her interview with the Argus Leader:



On Friday, Clinton met with the Argus Leader Editorial Board for an interview covering her stance on the issues and the state of her campaign.


Clinton described strategies to encourage alternative energy production and to improve conditions on South Dakota's reservations.



She also flatly denied reports that her campaign had been discussing an end to her campaign with Obama's representatives.


Clinton also vowed to keep her campaign going through South Dakota's primary.


But what made headlines nationally was a reference to the assassination of Bobby Kennedy in June 1968. Clinton referred to RFK in explaining that other primary campaigns had stretched into June, as hers will. In fact, she used another in the same breath - her husband's late victory in 1992.


But taken out of context, the reference to assassination was enough to spark a firestorm.



What follows is an edited transcript of the interview with Clinton. Argus Leader Publisher Arnold Garson, Executive Editor Randell Beck, Director of Administration Greg Robinson, Assistant Controller Barb Facile and Voices Editor Nestor Ramos conducted the interview.


Here's the transcript from the point where the Editorial Board begins to "turn the corner" of the direction of their interview questions:


EB: We're going to begin to turn the corner here a little bit with some other areas. Some of the biggest names in Democratic politics in South Dakota are on the Obama side of the ledger - former Senators McGovern and Daschle, for example. Who are your key people in South Dakota?


CLINTON: I just have a lot of grass-roots support. I have a very vigorous volunteer effort that understands the odds that we face but are undeterred. And I am very grateful for that. I think that if you look at this campaign starting in late February moving forward, I've done much better. The longer this campaign has gone on, the better I've done. Which I think is an interesting observation. I lead in the popular vote. More people have now voted for me, not only more than my opponent, but more voted for me than anyone who has ever run for the nomination of a political party in our country. There are a lot of people who really believe in me and support me because they think I would be the best president. I think having the campaign go on until the people in South Dakota actually get to vote is a very important part of democracy. I readily accepted Senator McGovern's offer that Senator Obama and I appear side-by-side. I have accepted that; I have urged that. I think that the people in South Dakota deserve it.


He doesn't seem to want to debate me or even appear on the same stage with me, which I think is kind of strange since he's going to have to certainly do that in the fall, I would expect, if he is our nominee. So I feel very good about my campaign, I'm very grateful for the support that I've received against pretty daunting mountains to climb because people have been declaring it over for many months and voters seem to have a different idea and keep coming out and voting for me, and I hope to do well here in South Dakota.


The EB now asks six consecutive questions that dance around the possibility of Senator Clinton dropping out of the primaries before the Democratic convention.


EB: The reports this morning and overnight were that your campaign had made certain contacts or overtures to Mr. Obama's campaign just in the past 24 hours and were working on some sort of deal for your exit.


CLINTON: That's flatly untrue. Flatly, completely untrue.


EB: No discussions at all.


CLINTON: No discussions at all. At all. Now I can't speak for the 17 million people who voted for me, and I have a lot of supporters. But it is flatly untrue, and it is not anything that I am entertaining. It is nothing I have planned. It is nothing that I am prepared to engage in. I am still vigorously campaigning. I am happy to be here. Looking forward to campaigning here.


Honestly, I just believe that this is the most important job in the world, it's the toughest job in the world. You should be willing to campaign for every vote. You should be willing to debate anytime, anywhere. I think it's an interesting juxtaposition where we find ourselves. I have been willing to do all of that during the entire process and people have been trying to push me out of this ever since Iowa.


EB: Why?


CLINTON: I don't know. I don't know. I find it curious because it is unprecedented in history. I don't understand it. Between my opponent and his camp and some in the media there has been this urgency to end this. Historically, that makes no sense, so I find it a bit of a mystery.


EB: You don't buy the party unity argument?


CLINTON: I don't because, again, I've been around long enough. You know my husband did not wrap up the nomination in 1992 until he won the California primary somewhere in the middle of June, right? We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California. You know, I just don't understand it and there's lot of speculation about why it is, but . . .


EB: What's your speculation?


CLINTON: You know, I don't know. I find it curious, and I don't want to attribute motives or strategies to people because I don't really know, but it's a historical curiosity to me.


EB: Does it have anything to do with gender?


CLINTON: I don't know that either. I don't know. I'm not one to speculate on that because I think I want to be judged on my own merits and I believe I am, but others have.


Here the EB has six questions about the same issue. Let me paraphrase this Q & A:


Q: Your people and Obama's people gonna do deal so you can bow out now?
A: No.


Q: No discussions about a deal?
A: No.

Q: Why so many trying to push you out of the race?
A: Don't know.

Q: Won'cha just drop out for the sake of party unity?
A: Nope - primaries go through June.

Q: What's your speculation about the speculation why you don't drop out?
A: Don't know.

Q: You speculate it's gender issues?
A: Don't speculate.


Here's how the EB paraphrases / parses these paraphrased answers

Reminder: No; No; Don't know; Nope; Don't know; Don't speculate.



EB: It sounds like what you're saying then is this: That South Dakotans who are certainly thinking ahead to voting on June 3 can be confident that there will be competitive race on the day they vote.


And having permitted her interviewers the prerogative of paraphrasing / parsing HER words, she takes the affirmative voice, and reparaphrases their paraphrasing / parsing:


CLINTON: That's right. That's right. Well, if I have anything to do with it. And the other thing that I want South Dakotans to really think hard about is winning in November. The electoral map is the target here and consistently over the last weeks, I have had a considerable lead in the electoral college calculation over my opponent. And a source that is, perhaps, suspect to all of us as Democrats but seems to have a pretty good track records, Karl Rove does a rolling assessment and ABC News got a hold of his maps and calculations last week. It coincides with everything that I've seen from every other source. If the election were held today, I would win. I would beat McCain, and McCain would defeat Senator Obama.


I respect Senator McCain. He's a friend of mine. But I do not believe that he has the right ideas for our country, and I do not believe he should be the president after George Bush. It would be like a continuation economically and in Iraq of Bush's policies. So I think Democrats need to think very carefully about this vote in South Dakota.


EB: If Obama were the nominee, would you campaign for him in those states?


CLINTON: Absolutely. Absolutely, I've said I will do anything and everything I'm asked to do. I am a Democrat, and I am an American, and I think the damage that George Bush has done to our country is considerable. Therefore, we must have a Democratic president. I think the odds are greater that I would be that president than my opponent. That doesn't mean he can't win.


EB: Fair enough. It sounds like your strategy to win essentially rests now on Michigan and Florida.


CLINTON: No. Neither of us has the delegates we need.


EB: But he's closer than you are.


CLINTON: He's slightly closer than I am, slightly. I mean less than 200 out of 4,400. One of us has to get to 2,210 and neither of us is near there yet. He keeps saying, 'Oh, but I've gotten to 2,025,' but that excludes Michigan and Florida. I don't think it's smart for us to have a nominee based on 48 instead of 50 states. Hopefully, Florida and Michigan will be resolved on May 31st when the DNC Rules Committee meets. But even then, we still have to convince superdelegates. Now, superdelegates are in the process for a purpose. Their task is to exercise independent judgment, and the independent judgment they should exercise is who is the stronger candidate to win in the fall. And, if they exercise that independent judgment, they should look at all the evidence, and they should make their conclusion. I'm waiting to see the electoral map that leads my opponent to the 270 electoral members. That's all I ask, and that's what a superdelegate should ask. Show me the map. It's not the math, it's the map. And I can show you the map about how I put together the 270 electoral votes.


EB: Senator, we really appreciate your time this afternoon.


CLINTON: Well, thank you.


EB: It was great to be able to pick your brain and thank you a lot, we appreciate it much.


CLINTON: My pleasure. Thank you all very much.



Real Threat Iran's Nuclear Program Poses

Commander Jeff Huber, U.S. Navy, retired, analyses inform in prose so accessible, so interesting, and frequently so damn funny, that they ought to be required weekly readings for U.S. junior high and high schools -- not to mention U.S. military academies and war colleges.


His recent smackdown to Thomas Friedman's theoretic "U.S. cold war with Iran"

We’re no more in a cold war with Iran than we were
in a cold war for 50 years with Belarus.


To prove his point, Commander Huber notes:


Iran’s ballistic missiles, if they work, can reach Israel, but ballistic missiles, as we saw in our first war with Hussein, are little more than incredibly expensive mortar rounds unless they have nuclear warheads, and the Iranians don’t have any nuclear warheads to put on theirs.


If Iran ever does possess nukes, it won’t dare use them; it would not survive the retaliation. If terrorists want someone to steal a nuclear warhead from, they don’t need to bother with Iran.


Pakistan has plenty of the little boogers, and its government is far less stable than Iran’s is ever likely to be.


Iran’s leaders have consistently said they have no intention of acquiring nuclear weapons.


Some people say they’re lying, but the people saying that are the likes of Dick Cheney and George W. Bush, whose relationship with the truth has been on the rocks for many years.



The REAL threat Iran's Nuclear Program Poses


The real threat Iran’s nuclear program poses is the very good possibility that it will grow into a viable, self-sustaining nuclear energy industry. If that happens, the big losers will be Dick and Dubya’s buddies with Exxon/Mobil and in the Sunni oil producing nations who will have lost control of the evolution of the global energy market.

The big winners will be Iran’s sponsor nations, Russia and China.

(Whom many of you will recall, from the LAST cold war)


Those who comment on his posts also analyze insightfully:


There are two other good reasons why Iran wouldn't use nuclear weapons on Israel.


1) Israel is so small the fallout would spread into the neighboring countries (or worse if the missile veers off course).


2) Jerusalem is the third holiest city to Muslims. Well, ok, might be 4th to Shiites but the point still stands, they ain't gonna nuke one of the holiest of holies. That would be like Greece nuking Istanbul (Constantinople).

Another reader notes:


"If Iran ever does possess nukes, it won’t dare use them; it would not survive the retaliation."


Spot on Jeff, there isn't a government on what's left of this planet with a suicide wish. The perks of being in power, even if you are a small nation (better to be a big fish in a little pond), are too great.

And finally, The Reality Kid said...

I do believe that you are the most well-rounded, informed and informative analyst on the "Iran situation" writing anywhere. As much as I can about this particular issue/situation, I am thankful for your insights.

What is perhaps most impressive is your refusal to view the Bush administration's middle eastern policy as comprising an incoherent series of crazy acts, but instead, as potentially a deliberate (if wanton) strategy based on military- and energy-driven objectives.

While there are a few others who accept that this administration isn't so crazy as to be pig-headedly maintaining an obviously-failing policy in the M.E., and who recognize that maybe the policy is achieving, more or less, what's intended (i.e., objectives that have little to do with liberation and freedom), your accomplishment, in part at least, lies in how broadly-framed and well-grounded your analysis is.

In sum, it makes sense. Which is what I come here for.

Self Inflicted Economic Misery

At Asia Times Online Julian Delasantellis waxes nostalgically about olden days when Congressional budgetary actions signed into law by the President were thought to be at least as effective as the Federal Reserve Board's actions to keep movements of the economy under control.

As examples, Delasantellis notes LBJ's 1967 push for a 10% income tax surtax "to deal with the inflationary effects of Vietnam War deficit spending" and Ronald Reagan's "
budget-busting tax cuts and defense buildup" to deal with the stagflation of 1981.

Although there were consequences - the Vietnam War and the income tax surtax drove LBJ from office, while Reagan and Congress enjoyed the pursuits of their fiscal policies which permitted them to "
ladle tax cuts and government spending over their constituents like thick country gravy. "

Excellent stuff here. Please note:

(1) Deficit war spending is inflationary.

(2) President and Congress like to give TAX CUTS and GOVERNMENT SPENDING to
their constituents.

Delasantellis points out that Congress and the Fed are working at cross purposes, with Congress giving a $307 bn farm bill over five years along with a $160 bn "fiscal stimulus / rebate" initiative to spur the economy, while the Fed continues to rapidly lower interest rates to keep inflation at bay.

In a refreshingly candid and vivid image of utter madness, Delasantellis mentions the urging of American consumers to spend their stimulus / rebate checks on "more imported Chinese home electronics."

Additional notes

(3) We don't make much hi-tech consumer stuff here no more.

(4) We ARE the world's #1 arms dealer with about 50% of market share.

Of course, the reason the Fed lowered interest rates so often, so fast, and so much is to keep the stock markets propped up. After all, as long as the markets are up, the economy is doing well. No?

The key conclusions:

[A] By selling controlling interests in 100's of LARGE (formerly U.S.) companies and U.S. government debt, America has sold away the right and the ability to control its own economic destiny. U.S. economic woes have been self-inflicted.


[B] Elsewhere, the economies of China-India-Russia-Brazil are going well. There's a party going on. We're not invited.






Wednesday, May 28, 2008

The Great Western Delusion


Jean Bricmont has an thoughtful piece today in Counterpunch:

Per Bricmont, The Great Western Delusion sees a world full of peoples "oppressed by their own governments, run by political dictators and economic mismanagers" seeking support of liberation "by the good, democratic, liberal, open market West."


IMO, the GWD is one of several "pleasing" narrative - spun by politicians, op-ed writers, talking heads from the military-industrial-infotainment-financial complex - to help gin up support for the latest invasion and occupation efforts (politico-military blunder), the first in a series of such narratives.


Any and all dissent to the newest "mission (invasion - occupation)" is handled by a another "pleasing" narratives - those who oppose the war do not support the brave troops, and are thus de facto traitors. Dissenters are liberals and intellectuals who spit on the troops.


Once the invasion mission has "been accomplished", another "pleasing" narrative emerges - how wonderful our war-making technology has worked and how heroic our sacrificing soldiers are. Video-game like coverage of the war plays non-stop on cable news (while the cable news rating spike upward).


As the occupation continues, and the occupied "dead-enders and terrorists" resist, yet another narrative emerges. Because of the "dead-enders and terrorists" "our troops" have to stay to "complete the mission" - to bring freedom to the freedom loving peoples of this invaded and occupied nation.


The final narratives start to play out when the things get so bad - meaning "our things" - our soldiers' blood and the hemorrhaging our nation's treasury, as well as "our" costs for food, housing, transportation, education, infrastructure maintenance and repair rising because of inflation as the government prints more money to keep funding the war ever higher levels.


Yes when things get so bad for US, that "we" decide to remove our occupying army.


Since the world's sole super-power, with all of it's technological might, and the best soldiers in the world could not "win" the invasion and occupation, obviously, the "war" was not prosecuted as it should have been. Better administration / planning would have saved the day. The competence of the current political administration is questioned. The pleasing narrative - "had but the war been prosecuted more competently, we would have won."


Then someone must give the order to withdraw the troops. Whomever that President is, will come to be viewed as "The President Who Lost the War." Presidents would prefer to resign office rather than be known as a war-losing President.


As time begins to elapse post-withdrawal, the final narratives begin. The first narrative is spun by the military. "We were on the verge of victory, but our hands were tied behind our back. We were but six months short of total victory when the liberals, the hippies, the intellectuals, the Democrats forced us to withdraw."

And the final narrative is wound and spun -- we were not defeated by an external enemy, but by an enemy within - by traitors within our midst. We were stabbed in the back. Never again. Round them all up, all the traitors, or, at least, keep a very watchful eye on them. Telecoms - take note.


I mention in passing that the viewpoints of all such narratives are U.S.-centric. The calculus of the death, the misery, the destruction, the physical and psychological devastation to the living and murdered souls of the land invaded - "collateral damage" - another pleasing narrative, much more palatable than murdered and mutilated children, women, civilians, hospital workers, merchants, teachers, office workers, laborers, families, is virtually NEVER a consideration.


One of the lessons learned from the American Invasion and Occupation of Vietnam was DO NOT under any circumstances ever again show the public uncensored pictures of war.


Echoing Tom Englehardt, this key graf from Bricmont's piece:

The reason it is a delusion is that it misses the fundamental change in the 20th century, at least the one which has had the greatest long lasting impact. This is not the history of fascism or of communism, which indeed belong to the past, but decolonization. Not only did this movement free hundreds of millions of people from a particularly brutal form of racist domination, but it inverted what had been the dominant trend in the history of the world since the end of the 16th century, namely the movement of European expansion. The 20th century marked the decline of Europe, and the replacement of Europe by the US as the center of the world system is likely to be short lived.

...

The problem of the US and Western elites is not only that they are willing to pursue violent policies in favour of their interests, but that they also pursue violent policies against their interests, because of their unbounded arrogance. We no longer control the world and great miseries follow from the non acceptance of this fact.




Monday, May 26, 2008

This Election (Too) Can Be Stolen

I'm very troubled by the venom being spewed by supporters of both Senators Clinton and Obama.

Maybe that's "just politics as usual." Well, politics as usual has not been working so well for me for the last ... interesting thought (for another post).

I commented extensively today on this piece by Digby:


The "narrative(s)" for a McCain victory have already been written, aided and abetted by the level of vitriol on the left, i.e.,

(a) The "eruption" within the Democratic party between "rabid" Clinton supporters and "cultist" Obama supporters [with a McCain election seen as the Clinton's final stab-in-the back to the Party]

(b)The "racism" of white Northern "blue collar" workers [again inflamed by the Clintons - so the narrative will go]

(c) The generic "elitist slur" being hurled like hand grenades at an Obama candidacy (replaying remarks already made by Clinton to the same effect)

(d) The general "ennui" of the "public" that the Democrats weren't even able to get "their" act together to nominate a candidate until June / July -- unless something "interesting" occurs at the Democratic Convention -- "a shriek", "violence in the streets", failure to nominate on the first ballot, a brokered convention -- all ablaze before the eyes of the country which concludes "We can't really trust the Democratic Party" (and don't doubt for one second that there will be republican operative at the convention stirring up boat loads of trouble. Replay Chicago, 1968 ).

(e) The "luster" coming off of Obama as he came to "see himself as the annointed one" and a "control freak" to boot.

(f) Attention to focus on Michelle Obama -- with inevitable comparisons between her academic and professional career with ... the academic and professional career of ... the 42nd President's wife. Elect Obama and get another first lady just like ...


That's how the narratives will go, should McCain "win" the election.


Narratives notwithstanding, this election can still be stolen.

1. What has been done about the disenfranchisement of Black voters in Florida -- via the fictious felons' list from 2000?

2. What has been done to speed up voting lines in Ohio -- in the inner cities; at the college campuses?

3. What plans does the Obama campaign have to ensure that the vote that can be gotten out will be allowed to vote? What plans does the DNC have to see that stronghold voters will be able to vote conveniently?

In states where Republicans control the apparatus of voting - be assured, the inner cities will have fewer voting booths per precinct, and address changes of precincts happening with little notice.

Similar shenanigans will occur at "liberal" universities in states with Republicans in control.


Whomever wins the Democratic nomination, an dilligent ground effort will be required in all 50 states, but especially in "swing states" where the Republican party controls the voting apparatus. And that requires boots on the ground. And that means a united combined effort of all factions of the Democratic party, no matter whom their partisan candidate.


Without such an effort, IF this election can be stolen, it WILL be stolen. Right in plain sight. And with the MSM all in line (remember, their corporate owners have a vested interest Republican politicians; and failing that, they'll take the most corporate-compliant Democrat).


And if the election IS stolen, there will be sufficient finger-pointing and name-calling on the left to obscure the larger issue of theft (once again).



Tuesday, May 20, 2008

Military-Industrial-Political-Infotainment-Financial Complex

It really isn't all THAT complex. They're all related and have a certain inbred mentality about how to "do business."

Possible Republican VP Candidate

Historical retrospective on Phil Gramm from Henry C K Liu published in Asia Times On Line:


Phil Gramm, who began his political career as a Democratic congressman in the Texas populist tradition, changed party affiliation to become a neo-liberal Republican senator from Texas. As Republican chairman and ranking member of the Senate Banking Committee, he spearheaded the Gramm-Leach-Bailey Act of 1999 with the conviction that higher bank profits commensurate with higher risk were the salvation of the economy, reversing the age-old principle that banks should be the economy's most risk-averse institution.


Between 1995 and 2000, Gramm received more than $1 million in campaign contribution from the securities and investment industry, more than he received from oil and gas interests that traditionally were a key source of financial energy in Texas politics. After retiring from politics, Gramm became vice-chairman of the investment banking arm of Union Bank of Switzerland (UBS), an institution at present in the spotlight for massive losses from subprime mortgage exposure. Gramm has been an economic adviser to the presidential campaign of Republican candidate John McCain since summer 2007. He is also rumored to be one of several possible running mates to McCain for 2008.


Gramm became linked to the Enron scandal when it came to light that his wife, Wendy, while serving on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, was involved in granting an exemption for Enron from federal oversight, immediately after which she was named a director at Enron. It came to light later that Gramm had helped to turn the regulatory exemption into law as well as push through the deregulation of energy markets that led to the Enron scandal. During this period, Enron was a major contributor to Gramm's political campaigns.




(MG) There we have it - the Straight Talk Express, brought to we,
the people by those who have also given us


Silverado (and other) savings & loan scandal - the Keating 5

Enron

Sub-prime mortgage meltdown




Sunday, May 18, 2008

Government programs that work must

Politicians who have told us government IS the problem truly believe it, and then go about governing so as to prove their point.

From the King of Zembla blog comes this memorable indictment of what conservatives MUST do to reinforce and affirm their pre-conceived beliefs about governance:

Government programs that work must be watered down, undermined, or dismantled altogether, lest citizens draw the naive and dangerous conclusion that government programs can work.

Friday, May 16, 2008

Conflating counterinsurgency with counterterrorism

Chet Richards, writing at the Defense and National Interest web site, recommends a book from the Cato Institute. He includes this excerpt:


By insisting that Iraq was ours to remake were it not for the Bush administration’s mismanagement, we ignore the limits on our power that the war exposes and in the process risk repeating our mistake …



More excerpts:

The experts who say more American planning would have saved Iraq confuse the power to conquer foreign countries with the power to run them.

...

In attempting to build foreign nations, the United States is unable to impose a national idea, and our liberalism, thankfully, limits our willingness to run foreign states through sheer terror.



Here's an example of the limits of our willingness to run foreign states through sheer terror:

Clifton Hicks and his comrade, Steve Casey, are giving testimony about their experience in a "free-fire zone" because there were "no friendlies." According to a numbers cruncher later on, their company had killed between 700 and 800 enemy combatants, however, Hicks and Casey never saw any enemy combatants. In November of 2003, according to Hicks, an AC-130 gunship opened fire on an apartment complex. There was prior-notice given to the company, according to Hicks, by a Lieutenant Colonel about "putting on a show" for the boys. Later, the apartment was annihilated as Casey and his comrades watched and cheered from the roof of a nearby building. Casey states that he never thought about it at the time, but now the loss of so much civilian life truly bothers him.


Hicks is testifying that this building demolition was the most destructive act he's seen in his entire life, and it was not a legitimate military target. A sniper team could have neutralized the enemy sporadically firing from that location, but leadership instead chose to destroy the entire building and the civilians inside.


Abu Grahib, another example of such limits.




The final reason that American will not master counter-insurgency and state building is that we do not have to. Winning small wars has never been essential to American security. ... the attempt to establish control of hostile societies is a source of insecurity.

...


These ideas conflate counterterrorism with counterinsurgency. Counterterrorism is best accomplished by police intelligence operatives and special operation forces. We can hunt and capture or kill the small minority of jihadists who seek to attack Americans ... but we need not establish control over foreign states in order to do so.



Occupations convert extremists who would otherwise concern themselves with resisting their own governments into international terrorists interested in killing Americans.



Hidden costs of the war

Justin C. Cliburn live-blogged the Winter Soldier Hearings. He had these observations about the hidden costs of the war:

I want to [say] this about the cost of the war at home: I deployed to Iraq with 150 men, not all of them were married. Since we've returned, 60 have been divorced ... over half of the married men.


[Kris] Goldsmith knew that he wanted to get out and go to college. He was about to get out of the military when George W. Bush announced "The Surge", which put 20,000-30,000 troops on Stop Loss, including Kris. The day before Kris was supposed to deploy back to Iraq, he attempted suicide with prescription pills and alcohol. After spending a week in a mental health ward, Goldsmith was discharged.


EndStopLossNow.org reports 80,000 soldiers are on Stop Loss right now.


On Kris' DD 214, it says MISCONDUCT: SERIOUS OFFENSE. The serious offense? A suicide attempt due to mental illness.


The Stop Loss program is killing our troops, physically and emotionally. These men and women lived up to their side of the bargain; it's time for the military to do the same.


The breakdown of the military
includes those who got out of the military because of a matter of conscience.


As an institution, the VA has still not implemented a single recommendation from the 1980s VA report of PTSD. We won't find Jeffrey Lucie on any list of OIF/OEF casualties, but he and others like him are the forgotten veterans and forgotten casualties. 120 veterans take their lives per week while the government does one study after another without any real change.

Kevin asks, "Where is the rage?" When are we going to truly honor and support our veterans? How can we support our troops when funding for PTSD was stricken from the 2005 supplementary budget?


U.S. weakness apparent to casual observers

Karen Kwiatkowski makes some very good points in her article, The Art(ifice) of War


Sun Tzu would have us feign weakness in the face of an enemy that impresses us, in order to confuse and mislead him. Instead, we boast – as recently relieved CENTCOM commander Fallon suggested – that we will crush our insignificant enemy like ants. One wonders towards whom such language is directed. I suspect our logistic, financial, tactical, strategic and moral weakness is apparent to the most casual observer throughout the Middle East and the world. Only the American heartland waits anxiously for the latest pump-me-up story from Washington.

No. The Americans in the heartland await and pray anxiously every day for the safe return of their sons and daughters, brothers and sisters, fathers and mothers, serving in the U.S. military in Iraq and Afghanistan. The blood costs of this war are all to visible in communities across the country.

This artifice of war, cherished by neoconservatives and the other moral dimwits in Washington and New York, must be turned upside down. Remember – it’s not war! To understand what it is, and it is indeed complex, one must avoid the New York Times and check out Winter Soldier, held in DC this past weekend. Listen to IVAW member and Winter Soldier participant Geoff Millard, interviewed here by Scott Horton before the event, and by me just afterwards.


Sun Tzu wrote of war as an art – but Iraq today isn’t war in a Sun Tzu sense. Sun Tzu understood war as extremely expensive, extremely deadly, and an existential threat for the initiating emperor. Truly, our fun and games in Iraq meet these criteria. But wise strategists view war as a serious national decision – not a weekend blockbuster, measured by tickets sold, budgets exceeded and stars showcased.


From Majesty to Hedge Fund Dust

In an Asia Times Online article, Julian Delasantellis chronicles the demise on Sears & Roebuck, concluding:

... [T] he sorry saga of Sears illustrates just how far distorted American ethics and values have become from exposure to the great credit and money carnival of the past few years. "All that is solid melts into air, all that is holy is profaned," Karl Marx wrote in 1848. In this case, nobody thought twice, nobody blinked an eye, when Wall Street took a truly unique American institution, Sears, and turned it from a fine, respected American society matron into a common streetwalker reduced to pimping through the night for Eddie Lampert.

Last year, the New York Times' Gretchen Morgenson noted that more American national income was produced by financial engineers, people like Lampert who manipulate the amorphous abstraction called money, than by the mechanical engineers who manipulate actual physical realities such as steel, concrete, mortar and oil. In his new book Bad Money (reviewed May 10 by Joe Costello), Kevin Phillips notes that "By 2004-6, financial services represented 20 to 21 percent of gross domestic product, manufacturing just 12 to 13 percent."

Somewhere along the line, America got the idea that the buck generated from financial services, from manipulating money, from passing it from hand to hand, was equivalent, or even superior to (after all, you come home with a lot better smelling clothes after a day on the trading floor compared to a day at the steel mill) the same buck made actually making and sustaining something - such as the great brand Sears once was.

Here is the actual core of the current crisis of American overconsumption. The music has stopped, the dance is over, the great credit and money creation machine of the past few years has shut down. As the dust settles, we see that, for all the money, and supposed wealth, created over the past few years, very little of actual value, of real worth remains. As does now Lampert's, as does now America's, and its dream of endless wealth created through little or no actual work, phantasms still dance into and out of our world with the pages of a calendar, and only the very foolish mistake their ever-vertiginous presence with reality.

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

The long suicide

Reading through some comments on a Fabius Maximus piece, I came across this arresting thought from oldskeptic



The “Long War” might be more accurately called the “Long Suicide” … though it might not be so long.


Some Russian commentators were recently saying that the Putin Government thinks the US is in a death spiral. I have nightmares that they might be right.


To which Fabius Maximus replied, in part,


... it does look a bit depressing, but we have pulled ourselves out from worse holes. At some point it comes down to faith in the American People. Without that, the only alternative is to choose a Patron.



I'd suggest that by "the American People", the author means a movement, or combination of movements, quite a bit greater than a President, or a Political Party.


I'd further suggest that for the American People to do "the right thing" will entail a great level of internal turmoil and and conflicts of interest.


The question, "what kind of a nation do 'we' wish 'ours' to be" must be addressed. Most assuredly, the leaders we elect reflect tellingly on 'our' answer to that question.

Monday, May 12, 2008

Blistering honesty from the American Conservative

Note: this post was modified with some additional thoughts italicized towards the end.

In the April 21, 2008 issue of The American Conservative, Andrew
Bacevich has an article entitled Surging to Defeat which notes the following:


Although violence in Iraq has decreased over the past year, attacks on coalition and Iraqi security forces continue to occur at an average rate of 500 per week. This is clearly unacceptable. The likelihood that further U.S. efforts will reduce violence to an acceptable level—however one might define that term—appears remote.


Bacevich also points out that the "reduction" in violence (which started increasing in April) can be attributed to factors other than The Surge.


Furthermore, recent improvements in security are highly contingent. The Shi’ite militias, Sunni insurgents, and tribal leaders who have agreed to refrain from violence in return for arms, money, and other concessions have by no means bought into the American vision for the future of Iraq. Their interests do not coincide with our own, and we should not delude ourselves by pretending otherwise.



With a blistering honesty encountered seldom in the so-called MSM, Bacevich details the initial stated purpose of the surge:


Unfortunately, partial success in reducing the level of violence has not translated into any substantial political gains. Recall that the purpose of the surge was not to win the war in a military sense. Gen. David Petraeus never promised victory. He and any number of other senior officers have assessed the war as militarily unwinnable. On this point, the architects of the surge were quite clear: the object of the exercise was not to impose our will on the enemy but to facilitate political reconciliation among Iraqis.


A year later, signs of genuine reconciliation are few. In an interview with the Washington Post less than a month ago, General Petraeus said that “no one” in the U.S. government “feels that there has been sufficient progress by any means in the area of national reconciliation.”


...

Iraq today qualifies only nominally as a sovereign nation-state. It has become a dependency of the United States, unable to manage its own affairs or to provide for the well-being of its own people. As recent events in Basra have affirmed, the Iraqi army, a black hole into which the Pentagon has poured some $22 billion in aid and assistance, still cannot hold its own against armed militias.


This Iraqi army is NOT the Iraqi army that dissipated in the face of U.S. armed forced march to Baghdad. That army elected to not fight. And then was disbanded, leaving it's soldiers, many of whom had fought the dreaded Iranian army to a standstill (albeit with plenty of U.S. aid, munitions, chemical weapons, and satellite intelligence) with no income and plenty of incentive to join and help train militias.


The U.S. military victory in Iraq was swift. I hope that when the war colleges do their what went wrong analysis, they acknowledge that when a military victory leaving no one with whom to negotiate terms of surrender means a political stalemate (and continuing hell on earth for the people of Iraq and the troops in occupation there).


Repeat. The U.S. military victory in Iraq was swift. We rid the country of a despotic dictator. We eliminated the despotic dictator and destroyed the non-existent weapons of mass destruction. Our military is quite efficient at killing and destroying stuff. Lots of fire power. Lots of bombs. Lots of planes. Huge ships. Many computers and computer visuals. Should have proclaimed "Mission Accomplished" and returned home.


But this is not like the so-called "great wars". Of course not. The U.S. INVADED Iraq, and OCCUPIES the country. Millions of Iraqis have been displaced, died, or dispersed out of their country. And they blame us. Only willful blindness can prevent anyone from seeing why we are blamed, or for concluding that the U.S. decision to invade and occupy Iraq is the root cause of turning Iraq into a hell on earth for the Iraqi people.


Bacevich estimates the present day costs in treasury and in blood. The longer term costs will be even more substantial.


The costs to the United States of sustaining this dependency are difficult to calculate with precision, but figures such as $3 billion per week and 30 to 40 American lives per month provide a good approximation.


And then asks the single question that supporters of the war don't want to answer or even address:


What can we expect to gain in return for this investment? The Bush administration was counting on the Iraq War to demonstrate the viability of its Freedom Agenda and to affirm the efficacy of the Bush Doctrine of preventive war.



The Bush "Freedom Agenda" was never about freedom for human beings. Of course, Americans are for freedom. It's an American value, after all. Land of the free, etc. But "Freedom Agenda" is just a catchy phrase, buzz word palliatives for something entirely different agenda, as noted in an Open Democracy article by Bob Burnett:


The focus of the freedom agenda wasn't repressive regimes, but rather closed markets.


The neocon dialectic


On 6 June 2007, during Bush's trip to the G8 summit, he reaffirmed the freedom agenda in a speech in Prague. Behind his noble words was the president's unwavering insistence on open markets. Patricia Cohen reported that Bush told G8 leaders "political liberty is the natural byproduct of economic openness." He expressed the dogmatic neo-conservatism that guides his administration: "open your markets and democracy will surely follow."


The mechanical, neo-conservative nostrum that unrestrained capitalism gives rise to democracy has guided Bush administration foreign policy in Iraq, the middle east, and the rest of the world; and has had a powerful impact on US domestic policy. Unfortunately, the Bush doctrine has failed everywhere it's been applied. Open markets didn't produce democracy in Iraq, because the American-led occupation neglected to provide for the prerequisites of democracy: namely, a viable institutional infrastructure enabling civil society to operate effectively.


Interestingly, what Burnett refers to as a "neo-conservative nostrum", Immanuel Wallerstein calls Neoliberal Globalization -- a program led by Reagan in the U.S. and Thatcher in England and abetted by the IMF and the World Bank; a program also referred to as the Washington Consensus.


Wallerstein notes the political successes of the Washington Consensus: the fall of Communists regimes in eastern Europe and the former U.S.S.R. and China adopting market-friendly policies.


But Wallerstein also remarks on a conundrum. Economic success (of the policies of privatizing industries, reducing trade restrictions, and cutting back on the welfare state) failed to follow. The surge of stock markets everywhere based mostly on speculation rather than profits from production. Furthermore, while the rich got richer, especially the very rich, real income fell for much of the rest of the world.


So "neoliberal globalization" is a "neoconservative nostrum." Makes for difficulties in separating liberals from conservatives.


Per Bacevich, the military was used to "imprint liberal values". Again, this makes for difficulties in separating liberals from conservatives.

the war has long since failed. Rather than showcasing our ability to transform the Greater Middle East, Operation Iraqi Freedom has demonstrated just the opposite. Using military power as an instrument for imprinting liberal values in this part of the world has produced a failed state while fostering widespread antipathy toward the United States.

Rather than demonstrating our ability to eliminate emerging threats swiftly, decisively, and economically—Saddam Hussein’s removal providing an object lesson to other tyrants tempted to contest our presence in the Middle East—the Iraq War has revealed the limits of U.S. power and called into question American competence. The Bush Doctrine hasn’t worked. Saddam is long gone, but we’re stuck. Rather than delivering decisive victory, preventive war has landed us in a quagmire.

The abject failure of the Freedom Agenda and the Bush Doctrine has robbed the Iraq War of any strategic rationale. The war continues in large part because of our refusal to acknowledge and confront this loss of strategic purpose.


The war also continues because our politicians do not have the will to end it. This scenario has played out before, in Vietnam. Presidents Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon all knew that war could not be won. But to withdraw the troops, to pull out, would be perceived as a military defeat, and no President wants to to preside over a U.S. military defeat. The recriminations would be vitriolic. Such a defeat could only happen from sabotage from within: traitors to blame. The traitors would of course be, the political party in office at the time of the eventual withdrawal, and all who opposed the war in the first place. The traitors, the internal enemy. The commies, the pinkos, the dirty hippies -- pacifists, intellectuals, liberals, women. The usual suspects plus immigrants, and certain liberal protestant denominations.


For, how can the world's largest military super-power, a nation that spends more money on the military and national defense than all the rest of the world combined, how can such a military force lose to a guerrilla insurgency?


One simple answer is this: to utilize an efficient killing and destructive machine to gain a political end will highlight your efficiency at killing and destroying, not your ability to compromise or negotiate. It will demonstrate your cruelty and callous indifference, not your strength. And ultimately your weakness, both politically, and militarily.


Is it a liberal, or a conservative value to use war to implement a geopolitical goal?


Answer. It is neither. It is a warmonger's value to use war to implement a geopolitical goal.

And such wars are crimes, for all the world to see; for all the world to judge.


Will America ever have leaders of such integrity?

Writing for the Asia Times Online, Sami Moubayed relates a telling story of Syria's first President Hashem al-Atasi.

Of Atasi's scrupulous integrity and character wikipedia says:

"amid the confusion and violence that often formed the background of Syrian republican history, he stood out as a man of sound principles dedicated to constitutional methods of government."



He was clearly a devout Muslim, inspired by the example of the life of the Prophet (peace be upon him).
Sami Moubayed's article begins as follows:


In 1936, a senior aid approached Syria's new president Hashem al-Atasi, explaining the presidential budget which had a special clause for "classified activities". This was a special amount allocated by parliament for the president to distribute at will, without presenting receipts, or explaining himself to the legislative branch.

Fuming, Atasi crossed off the amount and angrily snapped, "This is incorrect! A president should not have money to distribute freely without being checked by parliament. It is not his right and it is not his money." The late Syrian leader returned the money untouched - every single year - to the Syrian treasury during his
tenure, 1936-1939, 1949-1951 and 1954-1955.

...
Then, "classified activities" were relatively simple; they included paying Lebanese newspapers to refrain from criticizing Syria and distributing gifts to certain Arab leaders.

Atasi reasoned that this "classified activity" was being funded by Syrian tax money and that the average Syrian had a right to know where his taxes were being spent. As long as this money was not being used to improve the livelihood of ordinary Syrians, then it was a crime for any leader to spend it on political or clandestine activities.



How many of the current U.S. Presidential Candidates would we expect to follow such an example?

And yet, in a democracy of the people, by the people, and for the people, why should we the people expect anything less?




Saturday, May 10, 2008

Transmitting extremist right-wing ideas into the mainstream

In an April 24, 2008 post on his Orcinus website, Dave Niewert dissects the formula Floyd Brown, creator of the Willie Horton ad campaign that helped torpedo the Dukakis Presidential campaign in 1988, uses to inject extreme right-wing theories into the mainstream media.

Brown was recently quoted in a Time article by Michael Sherer :

"The campaign by Hillary Clinton has not been able to raise Obama's negatives," said Brown on Monday. "It is absolutely critical that Obama's negatives go up with Republicans."

But who's following the Clinton campaign now? Probably NOT Republicans. Obama's negative with Republicans is that he's a Democrat (and a socialist, so I've heard at the local barber shop). The point of Brown's ad campaigns, which are only now beginning, is to increase Obama's "negatives" with Democratic and Independent voters.

Here's Niewert dissecting Brown's strategy:

That's the Brown formula:


Create an incendiary ad, typically reverberant with far-right (often racist) themes repackaged for more mainstream consumption;


spend a little bit of money in a few precincts,


let the Republicans involved look good with the soccer-mom contingent turned off by racially incendiary campaigns, by officially denouncing;


but still reaching the closet-racist bloc with the ad itself -- which of course gets national play in the mainstream media as it discusses the outrage that ensues.


This, of course, expands the audience exponentially, and for no added expense. Diabolical, really, but clever as hell.


It's important to understand that the media are being deliberately gamed here, but they have no excuse whatsoever, ethically speaking, for allowing this to happen. After all, this is Floyd Brown we're talking about here. He's played this game before -- many, many times -- and has boasted afterward about how easy the media were to manipulate. But they never learn. Or perhaps they don't want to learn, because it makes for an easy narrative, and there's nothing they love like easy narratives.

It's also been striking how often the narrative veers into a discussion of Rev. Wright and Obama's judgment, which is ostensibly the ad's chief storyline. But anyone watching it can see that there's a larger, underlying theme: the ad is all about associating Obama with black criminality and supposedly lax liberal policies to "blame" for it. It's all about scaring white suburbanites while giving them the cover of hand-wringing about his "judgment."


....

It's important to understand the role that people like Brown play. Not only does he enable the right to feed red meat to their more extremist elements while giving them a certain "plausible deniablity" (thus the official distancing, which Brown explicitly welcomes), he plays an even greater part in transmitting ideas from the extremist right into the mainstream, thanks largely to a complaisant media willing to lend him the mantle of credibility he doesn't deserve.