I wonder when (or if) the American people will ever do as the Russian people are doing: The protests against Vladimir Putin's party show the people have finally run out of patience with rigid, lawless elites
For Russia, this is the end of an era
The protests against Vladimir Putin's party show the people have finally run out of patience with rigid, lawless elites
Russia's prime minister, Vladimir Putin, with President Dmitry Medvedev, December 1, 2011. Photograph: Sasha Mordovets/Getty Images
Russia and its power-hungry leader Vladimir Putin are still reeling. The results of last week's parliamentary elections were a surprise, not just because of his party's low level of popularity but because they were allowed to happen.
In a totally controlled system his United Russia party would have won easily. But Putin has erected a facade of nominally democratic institutions and they went out of control. While there was clearly a great deal of cheating, United Russia won less than half the votes, with the electorate expressing massive alienation from the ruling elite.
How that alienation plays out in the presidential election in March is the next major issue. The protests in scores of cities on Saturday are being treated less violently by the police and more respectfully by state-controlled TV than in the past. Will Putin continue this softer approach as the March poll approaches? If he fails to get half the votes there will be a second round in which victory for him is not guaranteed, although no doubt his ballot-stuffers will work harder than last week.
The central lesson of last week's result is that Russia's post-Yeltsin era has ended. After the collapse in living standards and the wholesale privatisation of the 1990s under Boris Yeltsin and the political turbulence of his constant battles with the Duma, Putin emasculated the parliament and returned the country to stability. Surging oil and gas prices allowed enough cash to trickle down to wages and pensions to create an illusion of creeping prosperity.
Russia now faces annual budget deficits like almost every other major economy. Findings by the respected pollsters VTsIOM in November showed 53% citing low living standards as their top priority, with inflation, unemployment and poor healthcare running close behind. Nearly 40% complained of bureaucracy and corruption.
After last week's election Putin and his colleagues not only have to deliver economic growth and better social services, they have to bring in the rule of law for citizens as well as for businesses. This is not quite the same as democracy and human rights, which the VTsIOM poll showed to be important for only 9% of respondents.
There is much facile talk that Russia needs a middle class to anchor democracy, even though there is no automatic linkage between the two. China and Singapore are prominent examples of countries with authoritarian systems and a large middle class. Russia's trouble is the absence of law, with its clear and enforceable rules. The communist system collapsed in part because many of its previous defenders travelled abroad and wanted the consumer goods and the modernity as well as the intellectual freedom they saw. Russia's post-Soviet generation travels and studies abroad in much vaster numbers. They feel shamed by their rulers' criminality.
No wonder so many young Russians choose to emigrate when they see how justice is administered selectively, the rich pay no tax and officials charge fees for services that should be normal civic entitlements. Vladimir Pozner, a well-known TV presenter, was right to say recently that many Russians have "a feeling of being totally unprotected". Igor Yurgens, head of the Institute of Contemporary Development (and a former supporter of president Dmitry Medvedev) complained that the Kremlin "underestimated the gap between a society that has become sophisticated and advanced and the feudal relations that operate at the upper echelons of state power".
It will take a large and sustained shift in elite attitudes for the problem to be rectified. But if Putin has any sense, last week's majority vote against his party will have got the ball rolling.